Morgan's movie Reviews on Newgrounds

[Clayland - Pico]

No no no.

Bad.
It has knox's style, which is also shit, so
you are VERY desprite.
Its very short and isnt much related to pico at all.
Just two shots of him(not moving)
Look in my profile, see the pic, I made that.
Match it.(PLEASE!!)

TechFlash responds:

I am not desperate at all, besides, Knox and I have different styles, like for one thing, my claymen are more fat, they also have bulgey eyes that do not blink, plus different voices, think THAT over!

[Tom Fulp VS Pico]

A bad flash

Sorry if im being straight out un-fair, but this had
apsolutly(sorry, bad speller) no orginality in it at all.
It also made no sence, and was too short.

The only thing that i will credit you on is that the credits rolled fast, the music was decent and the preloader was nice and simple.

Bogswallop responds:

Well at least your honest. Can't win em all :)

Originality is over-rated anyway XD

[Magic Mentos]

Very very nice short movie indeed.

Excellent man, just excellent.
Its so halarious and its very well made.
Great actors and gymnists(if you didnt use special effects!)
Short and sweet.
You bunch are very good filmmakers.
Enter this into a short film contest.

[Shoo Fly]

An excellent movie.

This is a VERY well made movie.
Its still amazing that you can pick up your flash skills
where you left off, 2 years ago! Very inpressive indeed.

-First, the animation was pretty amazing.
You are definenly disney material. Not how smooth it was,
just how you could make nelly "look" 3d. It was "real"!!
-Second, the artwork was pretty sweet. When people do a fantastic movie and everythings great, they usually overdo the backrounds. I dont believe that the style was very orginal as it was still anmie style.
-Thirdly, the music was VERY nice. You probelly wont reply, but can i get it on mp3 for general listening?
-Forthly, the nav. bar was quiet amazing. Probelly the best on newgrounds. I hope people learn from you and make one of these.
Its pretty fantasic. Just like as if i have a remote control!

- To finish, its a pretty amazing piece, its just pretty sad that we are either not going to see anymore work from you ever, or it'll take another very long time til the next one.

(Sigh...)

Ah well.
Thanks.
This is proving that there is really great animation talent on newgrounds.

(Ps, i agree with the last review too)

[-Go Away-]

Very nice indeed

The music was great.(nothing more to say about that...)
The stle of the whole thing together was pretty freakin nice.
It matched.
I hate one or two of those people(never heard of the others, tough they do sound like pricks...)

Cant really say much more except, keep it up!

[Feature Comforts (pilot)]

NO, oh god, NOOO!

That REALLY was a most horrible movie.
It wasnt even funny, not even SLIGHTY orginal or good
in ANY way.
Poor old arrdman, you have shamed the face of aardman, young boy, for punishment, you cant continue with this parady.

My god, it was a heap of SHIT!!!!
How didnt this get blammed i tell you...
HOOOOOOOOOOOOOOWWWWWW!!!!!!

[Winter Attack (part 1)]

OH no, not another late christmas stopmotion...NO!

No man, i dont know why people get this,
its march.
Save it til next year.
I definelly not in the spirit to be celebrating christmas on the
24th of March.

Besides that: the graphics were colourful and clear(i know it eats
up the filesize tough-its a tough decision to make, whether or not to use a high or low quality screen)

-The story was good enough, kinda pointless tough...
-The animation was pretty well achieved.Not much flaws or
little light flickers.
-The sets were very nicely done.
Strofome for inside the igloo was smart.
It suites it very well. Looks real.
-The sound and music worked very nicely.
-I liked the smooth camera movements.

Overall: would have done much better if it were christmas.
Be sure to get lots of reviews criticising this too.

I still give it a good mark as there is mostly just shit stopmotions
on newgrounds-but you are changing that.

MackProductions responds:

Thank you

but this isnt a christmas claymation, it is just that it takes place during the winter. Winter ended only 4 days ago so it isnt really that late. But it isn't meant to be a christmas film, just snow and winter.

[A Very Clumsy Christmas]

Pretty well done.

It was better than most clay movies you can find
on newgrounds and as a stopmotion animator myself, i can
see that this took a good bit of time.
The set and set pieces were EXCELENTLY crafted, something i cant do myself. What did you use to make them.

The animation itself was ok, wasnt great, kinda slow in places and fast in other places, and it felt robotic.
Nevertheless, they, aswell, were well designed charathers.

Another question, did you use "sculpey" clay?
It looks like that clay. Soft and squishy.
I used it once and hated it. I now use "newplast" clay.
FAR better. If you are not using it, look out fo it.
The wallace and gromit movie was made from it!
And its cheep!!

The music fitted it, but was one of those jingles that only work if its a cold christmas night, not a hot march day.
Anyway, great clay movie, i will look out for your stuff in future.
Well done!

RobsonStudios responds:

hey thanks! I used balsa wood, styrafoam, wall paper, and all other things for the sets. I'm HORRIBLE at animation but i try to make up for it with my sets and puppets. I use sculpey, its my personal favorite, I also use claytoon, not my pewrsonal favorite. New plast I have heard of, and i own a slab of it, its good stuff. Thanks for the review!

[Become]

I didnt believe that the full charather woube cool

I rarely say that any stopmotion flash on newgrounds is great but this was excellent.
It was short enough and had a pretty fun and ramdom story.
The quality of it wasnt bad despite what you said, and the finished charather was cool.

The music definely brought the life to it.

Very well edited.

Well done.

Besides the Over there series by dustball and gel, this is my favourite stopmotion flash.

[Toothpaste]

Good job.

Ok, first, the sound wasnt horrible.
Every last review i read states that the sound is most terrible
but its clear.

Anyway, you modeled a lot of chartathers in this one.
Wow.
And they are pretty detailed.

The story was deacent and the humour was just right for it.

As being a stopmotion animator myself, i believe that the animation wasnt great.
There just was arm movements and mouth movements.
Altough you edited it and lip synched it very well.
I was suprised about the eyes moving.
I know how to blink them, but the eyes are clay, not beads in this, how did you move the black pupils so carefully each frame?

Anyway, nice job.